Saturday, June 27, 2020

The Night Watchman


 The Night Watchman - Kindle edition by Erdrich, Louise. Literature ...
The Night Watchman by Louise Erdrich

This books takes as its backdrop a movement in the 1950s to "emancipate" Native Americans by terminating tribes' recognition as such by the federal government. The idea, according to its proponents was that this status had made indigenous peoples dependent upon the federal government and therefore held them back from their full economic potential. Of course, behind the scenes was a more dubious intent -- it was an opportunity, if successful, to wrest valuable lands away from Native Americans and put them in the hands of whites. It strikes me that this is another example of economic profiteers beginning with greed and then working backwards to come up with a justification; recently, many have pointed out that the same thing happened with racism. It's not that whites enslaved black Africans because they were racist, at least not at first. Rather, they enslaved black Africans because they wanted freed labor. Then, understanding, it seems, that enslaving another human being for personal gain is a bit...unrefined(?), they went through a lot of trouble mining the Bible, Greek philosophy, and pseudo-science to develop and spread the idea that people of African descent were inferior to whites. Racism. Basically, the white establishment has been terribly effective at enriching themselves economically, socially, and politically at the expense of the "other."

As Erdrich tells it, Mormon views on Native Americans evolved in the same way. Mormons apparently believe that Native Americans were one of four ancient groups who settled in the Americas; they are called the Lamanites in the Book of Mormon. The Lamanites were not a good people, and it was the job of the so-called Latter-Day Saints to bring them back to the Lord. I might be getting that wrong, but Erdrich through her characters seems to be indicating that this belief system ingrained the idea of Native American inferiority in the Mormon church, which encouraged its congregations to take land from indigenous peoples. It just so happens that the architect of tribal termination was a Mormon whose family's wealth came from their accrual of formerly Native lands. 

I will say that this part of history is a rather small part of the book. It is always in the background, but that is where it mainly stays. That disappointed me. I had heard Erdrich speak about termination on Fresh Air, and was fascinated by this here-to-fore unknown part of our past. I thought it would play a more prominent role. What Erdrich does really well, though, is bring the Turtle Mountain Tribe reservation of the 1950s to life. She makes you feel with the characters in a way that draws you into the story -- even if the plot is rather thin.

Tuesday, March 10, 2020

The Girl with the Louding Voice


Image result for the girl with the louding voice

The Girl with the Louding Voice by Abi Dare

I wanted to like this book. It tells the story of a young woman named Adunni, whose story begins in a small village in Nigeria. Though her plight begins before the narrative begins with the death of her mother, it worsens at the beginning of the novel when she is married, against her will, to a local man who has promised to pay her fathers' rent in exchange for Adunni. It is the first of Adunni's captivities, for no sooner does she escape the home of her new husband than she finds herself the maid of a tyrannical woman in the city of Lagos. She receives no pay for her work beyond the daily beatings she receives on behalf of her new employer. Nevertheless, through it all, Adunni remains hopeful and, in the end, is rewarded with a new life.

Obviously, the subject matter is important. It is a story of neo-slavery that hasn't been told much in the west. But the ending was evident from the beginning. From the moment Adunni learns of a possible scholarship for domestic servants, it is obvious that she will get it. But it takes the author more than a hundred pages for that inevitability to become a reality. In the meantime, the other events of the story don't offer much insight into the character or much in the way of suspense. For me, that left it a slog that I was happy to finish.

Monday, January 20, 2020

Kingdom of the Blind

Kingdom of the Blind by Louise Penny

I find myself these days looking for a book to get lost in. So I went looking for a mystery/detective stories. I haven't had great luck with these in the past, so was pleasantly surprised when I had trouble putting this one down. I basically read it cover-to-cover over the long MLK-day weekend.

This book is one of a series about Armand Gamache, a detective with something called the Surete du Quebec -- which has several accent marks I've left out -- that I assume is what they call the police force in our French-speaking neighbor to the north. In this one, there are three plot lines to follow. The first is a will for which Gamache, a neighbor friend, and an unknown third party are inexplicably named liquidators responsible for carrying out the deceased's wishes. Who was this person? Why did they put strangers in charge of the will? And why did it lead to a murder? Second is an investigation into Gamache himself that stems from actions he must have taken in a previous book. He is on suspension from his job as head of the Surete. Gamache seems fine with this, but his son-in-law, who also happens to work for him, is less comfortable with the situation. Higher-ups want him to sign some paperwork indicating that Gamache acted alone. Will he sign? How might this impact Gamache's future? Finally, the action for which Gamache is under investigation allowed a new powerful, and deadly, opioid into Quebec, and could hit the streets any day. Will Gamache stop it?

I appreciated how the author wove these narrative lines together so that they all stayed in the forefront of the reader's mind. I also was taken with the way she brought the characters to life. It is no mystery why she would serialize Gamache. It was also fun to be tricked a bit in the end. Throughout the book, you think you know what the characters know, even though the author tries to make it clear that you don't. Still, it is surprising to find out that Gamache was hiding something from the reader as well as his fellow characters. What might have really drawn me in, though, was the descriptions of rural Quebec in winter time. It seems like an idyllic place, albeit a cold one. I'll have to return to Gamache soon!

Sunday, January 5, 2020

The Lightning Thief

The Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan

I took up this book as an investigation into a possible unit I'd like to do with my students on heroes based on an inquiry I found from EL Education. The book imagines a world in which the Greek Gods are still around -- just not in Greece. Riordan explains that they live where the heart of "Western" civilization lives, which, at this moment in time, is, in his mind, in the United States. As they always have, the Gods continue to cavort with humans, creating demigods, some of whom are destined to become heroes in the vein of Hercules. One of these is Percy Jackson, who, spoiler alert, is the son of Poseidon, the god of the sea. His heritage, however, is unknown to Percy until he begins to be attacked by monsters ostensibly sent by the god of the underworld, Hades. No sooner does he find refuge in a summer camp for similar demigods than Percy is sent on a quest to resolve a spat between Poseidon and his brothers, Zeus and Hades.

I will say that this book lived up to its reputation as a page turner. It was pretty impossible to put it down. Though it can some times be a bit heavy handed, I also enjoyed for the most part the way Riordan wove Greek myths into a modern-day adventure. I'm not yet sure about its use in the classroom, though. The book is pretty much all plot -- I'm not sure there is much underlying the storyline that is ripe for discussion. But a good start to reading in 2020!

Sunday, September 22, 2019

Wandering Home


Image result for bill mckibben wandering home

Wandering Home by Bill McKibben

Another in my Wilderness Studies reading list. I have to say, I enjoyed this much more than I anticipated. It is McKibben's account of a walk he took from his home outside of Middlebury, Vt., to his home in the Adirondacks of New York. So it's a rich guy going for a walk.

But McKibben has some interesting things to say on this walk, particularly about wilderness and its definition. After a rumination on snow geese, for example, he writes, "If we're going to talk about wilderness...we ahve to face the truth that it's a little hard to separate out the natural and the artificial, a little hard to figure out exactly where we're planting our feet" (68). Exactly. I appreciate an author who is more about questions than answers.

Part of what keeps the book interesting is the cast of characters with whom McKibben makes his march. One portion of the hike he completes with the founder of the magazine Earth First!, a militant pro-wilderness publication. After years out west, this individual found his wilderness in the east: "I'd been in Tuscon five years. I was starting to really miss fresh water..I have the Eastern forst in my bones...wilderness [is] not just a Western thing" (79).

So maybe that struck me because I am in the midst of the eastern forest and often find myself pining for Western wildlands. But it strikes me, too, because I think it strikes to the fact that this elusive thing we call wilderness is really just a construction of our own minds. Wilderness is where we find it.

Case and point: In early August of this year, I was out on a pre-dawn jog on the dirt roads above our house. I was preoccupied and before I knew it I had stumbled on a steepish downslope, my shoulder had connected rather perfectly (or imperfectly) on a rock, and I was screaming in pain. In the suburban neighborhood where I'd grown up, my howls surely would have elicited some response from someone. But not here. I was in the woods. And they weren't woods that would fit the definition of wilderness in the Wilderness Act of 1964, But that didn't bring anyone to my rescue. So I started to walk out, every step sending a jolt of very strange pain up my arm.

To me, wilderness has always had a tinge of danger to it; it was a place where I wasn't in complete control. And it turned out, that place was far closer to my home than I thought.



Friday, September 20, 2019

The Solace of Open Spaces


Image result for the solace of open spaces 

The Solace of Open Spaces by Gretel Ehrlich

This slim volume is a continuation of the Wilderness theme that has been dominating my reading for the past few months. It contains a series of essays, more or less chronological, from a New York City transplant to the western side of the Bighorn Mountains.

I was drawn to the book because of its title. That solace mentioned is certainly something I have felt many times during my wanderings out west. That the book was set in one of those stomping grounds was a happy accident I discovered in its first pages. It was pretty great to be reading about familiar places -- Shell and Sheridan, for example -- that I'm hoping to visit next year.

But knowing those places also made it hard to read. There is always some discomfort in reading someone else's description of a place you love. In this book, that was compounded by the author's citified background and with the authoritative way she writes about the place. She seems to insist that her truths are the truths of the land, which makes me suspicious. For example, after complaining of the way culture has romanticized cowboys, she writes, "Because these me work with animals, not machines or numbers, because they live outside in landscapes of torrential beauty, because they are confined to a place and a routine embellished with awesome variables, because calves die in the arms that pulled others into life, because they go to the mountains as if on a pilgrimage to find out what makes a herd of elk tick, their strength is also a softness, their toughness, a rare delicacy" (53). Seems to me she's replacing one romantic vision with another -- and no romantic vision can be particularly accurate.

In the end, though, it was a passage near the end of the book that wound up coloring the whole experience for me. It came as the author was describing a sacred Native ceremony she had been invited to attend. After being approached by some young males, she writes, "...they flirted with me, then undercut the dares with cruelty. "My grandmother hates white tourists," the one who had been eyeing my chest said. "You're missing the point of this ceremony," I told him. "And racism isn't a good thing anywhere" (114). Her response to this situation strikes me as incredibly tone deaf and ignorant. First, she was a white tourist. But more importantly, the author participates in the Great American Myth of Racism, which is that it consists of actions and words. It's not. Racism is a system, one that creates institutions that privileged one group of people over all others. It's pretty clear that Native peoples are not the beneficiaries of American institutions. There is a reason that Ehrlich can easy move from New York City to Shell, WY, where she is free to write about a culture she barely knows, but Native populations have a hard time making the transition from the Spokane Indian Reservation to Spokane proper. Erhlich's comment in this situation demonstrates how unaware she is of her own privilege, how little she understands the role of race in our country, and how much she is willing to ignore about the past to celebrate the present moment in which she finds herself. How can we trust someone so willfully ignorant about such a fundamental fact of American life?

Wednesday, September 18, 2019

The Monkey Wrench Gang


Image result for the monkey wrench gang

The Monkey Wrench Gang by Edward Abbey

This year I'm launching a new elective at my school called Wilderness Studies. In addition to helping students deepen their thinking about wilderness, I'd like to connect them with literature about the outdoors. So many students read Hatchet and love it -- but never find another outdoorsy book they connect with as much. I read this one back in college, and thought it might be a good option for students.

The best part of the book, in my mind, is its opportunity for catharsis. It tells the story of three New Mexico strangers who meet on a raft trip down the Grand Canyon and who are drawn together for their disdain for modern encroachments into wild lands. So they decide to take action. They topple billboards, sabotage road-building equipment, and blow up bridges, all the while brilliantly evading their hapless pursuers. Their dream -- and I won't reveal whether they reach it -- is to topple the Hoover Dam, thus restoring Glen Canyon to its original beauty and rewilding the Colorado River. It is wonderful to see people fighting against modern consumerism and laziness and thoughtlessness and arrogance in such a brazen, successful way. I myself would love to blow up Rte. 107/12 between Pittsfield and Bethel and return the White River Valley to its wild state. What fly fishing it would be! Hayduke lives!

But I will say Ed Abbey has some strange ideas about wilderness. For the characters, and one can only assume Abbey himself, wilderness seems to be a place of unbound recreation for them. After all, they declare their love for littering roadsides with beer cans. Why? They don't like the road. And yet they love roads, as long as they are rough enough to keep their pursuers at bay but not so rough as to prevent their passage. It seems like a pretty selfish view of the wilderness.

The nail in the coffin for the book, at least for its inclusion in the course, though, is the way Abbey writes about the lone female character, Bonnie. She is, throughout the book, treated as an object. Abbey mentions her looks nearly every time she mentions her: "She looked lovely that morning: fresh as a primrose, the large violet eyes bright with exuberance and good humor, her mane of hair fragrant and rich, brushed to the gloss of burnished chestnut, glowing with glints of Scots copper" (165). Right. There is even a moment in the book when Hayduke rebuffs Bonnie's advances because he wants to ask Doc his permission to begin a relationship with her. As if Doc owned her. And all the while Bonnie knows these men are more or less bumbling idiots, she just can't resist them. She is definitely a figment of Abbey's imagination, his dream of a woman irresistibly and unquestionably drawn to his curmudgeonly self. I couldn't put the book in front of students without lots of discussion of this serious flaw in the book. And since these book clubs are meant to be more or less self run, that wasn't happening.